John Perry
Jared
Diamond’s theory of geographic luck has little or no difference in what the
book says. Jared Diamond has traveled across the planet looking for the answer
he was asked in Papua New Guinea, “Why you white men have so much cargo, and us
New Guineans so little? “ The answer is geographic luck. Thousands of years ago
when advanced civilization started showing up, it was clear where this was
happening. The fertile Crescent was the best place to be and was where the most
developed civilizations sprouted. This started with a working government,
shelter, and a good source of food and water. Papua New Guineans live in such
an isolated place, that there are no crops to be grown. The soil is not rich enough.
As for the Americans, they are highly advanced. Places with the same latitude
share the same climate. Between 8000-4000 B.C was the Agricultural revolution.
People started going from hunter gatherer to builder shelters with homes. This
is all a result of geographic luck.
This is a little disjointed, John. You touch on a couple of Diamond's points, but never really explain them. It's almost like this is an outline for an essay, not the essay itself.
ReplyDeleteI'm pretty sure with a little more effort a smart guy like you can do a lot better than this.
39/50